CHAPTER 35: EMPLOYMENT DISCRIMINATION 443
B20. Marvel Machine Corporation requires its employees to have a high school diploma,
claiming a definite connection between a high school education and job performance.
In a suit against Marvel under the Civil Rights Act of 1964, this requirement is shown
to have a discriminatory effect. Marvel has
a. an affirmative action defense.
b. a bona fide occupational qualification defense.
c. a business necessity defense.
d. no defense.
ESSAY QUESTIONS
B1. For twenty years, Ozzie works for Players Paradise, a destination for vacationers from
across the United States, maintaining golf carts. After a steady stream of positive job
evaluations and merit pay raises, Ozzie is promoted to the position of supervisor of
golf-cart maintenance at three of Players’s courses. Five years later, a new employee,
Quentin, is hired to oversee operations at all ten of Players’s courses. Quentin
demotes Ozzie, who is now over the age of forty, to running only one of the three cart
facilities, and freezes his salary. Quentin demotes five other employees over the age
of forty and places one of Ozzie’s former facilities under the supervision of Richie, who
is twenty-three. Ozzie overhears Richie say, “We’re going to have to do away with
these old, senile men.” Less than a year later, Quentin reconsolidates the three cart
facilities’ operations under Richie’s charge. Ozzie quits and files a suit against Players
for employment discrimination. Should he prevail? Explain.