McInnes/Kerr/VanDuzer: Managing the Law: The Legal Aspects of Doing Business, Fourth Edition
Chapter 19: Electronic Commerce
replies to Eta’s offer from his Vancouver office, indicating that he accepts her offer.
Morley’s email leaves his control at 4:52 pm (Vancouver time) and reaches an information
system within Eta’s control instantaneously. Eta waited in her office till 5:10 pm (Calgary
time), but received nothing (because of the one-hour time difference between Vancouver
and Calgary). The next day, when Eta found Morley’s email in her inbox (time stamped at
5:52 pm Calgary time), she phoned Morley to refuse the deal. According to the Uniform
Electronic Commerce Act, which of the following is TRUE?
a. Eta and Morley have definitely concluded a binding agreement, which was formed at
5:52 pm Calgary time.
b. Eta and Morley have definitely concluded a binding agreement, which was formed at
4:52 pm Calgary time.
c. Eta’s offer expired.
d. Morley accepted Eta’s offer, but the contract did not come into effect until the next
morning when Eta opened her email.
e. Once she opened her email it was too late for Eta to refuse the deal.
5) After becoming tired of the Muzak piped into your office, you decide to subscribe to an
online, listener-supported radio station dedicated to jazz and blues music. You had thought
that there was no upfront fee, but that listeners may make a donation using their electronic
wallets. Clicking through the site, you are asked to provide certain information on a
contractual form. One day, after several visits to the website, you notice a hyperlink
labelled “Terms of Service” while viewing the previous hour’s play list. You click the link
and a document opens, indicating that, by streaming music from the website, you have
agreed to pay a flat fee on a monthly basis with a minimum subscription of one year. On
your previous visits, you never noticed the hyperlink, which is barely visible in fine print,
at the bottom corner of the homepage right next to a flashy and distracting animation.
Which of the following BEST characterizes this situation?
a. You have entered into a contract and owe a year of monthly fees.
b. You can rely on Rudder v Microsoft to get out of this contract.
c. You have not entered into a contract.
d. You may have entered into a contract, but its terms likely do not include a year of
monthly fees.
e. You have entered into a contract that is governed by the Sale of Goods Act.