McInnes/Kerr/VanDuzer: Managing the Law: The Legal Aspects of Doing Business, Fourth Edition
Chapter 18: Intellectual Property
18) Woody has invented a method for instantly analyzing perfume, breaking it down into
its component chemicals and reproducing the scent. He is so excited about his invention, he
wants to tell the world. Which of the following examples of disclosure would be potentially
fatal to a patent claim?
a. He tells his wife that he thinks he has finally cracked the scent code.
b. He invites local cosmetics store owners over to see if any of them would be interested in
buying the invention.
c. He presents the invention to his lawyer to ask for advice on how to go about patenting it.
d. He tells his number one employee, on faith of a signed confidentiality agreement.
e. He writes the method on a piece of paper and puts it in his safety deposit box, to which
only he has access.
19) Distraught after having lost his cat, Jimmy Corpini drew up some designs for the “Kitty
Caller Collar.” The collar was designed so that when its wearer strays beyond certain limits,
a signal is sent to a receiver, which pinpoints the location of the collar. In anticipation that
one day he would get another cat, Jimmy printed off a copy of his design and emailed a
copy to himself. A year later, Jimmy moved, and Takashi moved into his home. While
cleaning the house, he came across the design. An engineer by trade, and cat lover by
nature, Takashi copied the designs and took them to the Patent Office, where he applied for
a patent on the collar, which he renamed the “CatchMeow.” In due course, the patent was
granted. Six months later, on the advice of an entrepreneur friend, Jimmy produced 100
Kitty Caller Collars, and began selling them at pet shows. He was unaware that Takashi had
patented his invention. The collars sold quite well, and Jimmy became something of a local
star in the community newspapers. Soon thereafter, Jimmy received a letter from a stern
lawyer informing him that he had to stop selling his Kitty Caller Collars, because by so
doing he was infringing the patent for the CatchMeow. Which of the following is the most
accurate assessment?
a. Jimmy is not liable for patent infringement since he is the true inventor.
b. Jimmy is not liable for patent infringement because his email sufficiently protects his
patent.
c. Jimmy is not liable for patent infringement so long as he can prove that he independently
came up with the design for the kitty collar.
d. Jimmy is liable for patent infringement but will be able to benefit from an exemption,
given that he is the true inventor.
e. Jimmy is liable for patent infringement because Takashi owns the patent.