8 Chapter Eleven
17. Gurth and Moretop, students, rented an apartment near the River City University. They hung
photographs on the wall using large nails for anchors. Several times, they brought the barbecue
indoors, which smoked up the walls of the apartment. They spilled soup and beer on the carpet,
which became discolored in such a manner that it could not be cleaned. Kilmer, the landlord, sued
them at the end of the lease for damages related to restoring the apartment to a “like new”
appearance.
a. When the landlord discovered that her apartment was being damaged, she should have evicted
the students. There is no liability for damages, because of her failure to do so.
b. The students must pay for damages, but only for those damages resulting from conduct beyond
ordinary wear and tear.
c. Anyone renting to students should know they are sloppy, so there is no liability.
d. The students must put the apartment in “as good as new” condition.
18. Ramey, the landlord, turned off all of the heat to Alvayay’s apartment during a cold spell in the
middle of a very cold winter. After Alvayay complained to the city housing authority, Ramey gave
him the required 30-day notice under the rental agreement. Alvayay refused to leave and Ramey
has now brought an action to evict. Alvayay’s best defense to an action brought by the landlord is
that there was a
a. retaliatory eviction.
b. periodic tenancy.
c. grace period.
d. constructive eviction.
19. Toufic rented a furnished apartment from Brown for 9 months — the University academic year.
They signed a lease prepared by the landlord, Brown. Brown had copies of the lease on his
computer, but when he printed up the version that was later signed by Toufic he forgot to include
any provision about who would be responsible for damage to the apartment. Toufic hosted several
parties during the year, highlighted by the NCAA College Basketball Championship party. Over 40
people attended and some of the guests did a slam dunk imitation on the apartment couch. Not
surprisingly, the couch broke. The term ended and Brown has claimed that Toufic is responsible for
the broken couch.
a. As a lease is an adhesion contract the landlord is liable for the damage to the couch.
b. Brown can collect for the damages, because it occurred while the apartment was under Toufic’s
control and exceeds ordinary wear and tear.
c. Toufic is liable for ordinary wear and tear to any apartment furniture.
d. A tenant is never responsible for damages caused by guests in an apartment.