c. complaint, answer, discovery, trial, verdict.
d. discovery, complaint, answer, trial, verdict.
Shirley Rhone suffered injuries when a truck struck the vehicle in which she was riding.
State Auto Mutual Insurance Co. was the insurer involved and provided personal injury
coverage. Shirley went to see Dr. Allen, a chiropractor who provided treatments 32
times over a 3-month period. Dr. Allen billed State Auto in three separate billings. After
paying the first two billings in full, State Auto expressed concern about whether Dr.
Allen’s charges were excessive. State Auto hired Chiropractic Consultants, Inc. to
evaluate Dr. Allen’s billings. The consultants advised that Dr. Allen’s billings were
indeed excessive. State Auto then telephoned Dr. Allen and offered a partial payment to
settle the account. After this conversation, State Auto issued and sent a check for $864
payable to Dr. Allen. On the face of the check, State Auto noted the total amount
allocated to each claim and typed ‘settlement in full.” On the reverse side it said, “The
endorsement of this draft by the payee constitutes a clear release and full settlement of
the claim or account shown on the other side.” Upon receipt of the check, Dr. Allen
cashed the check. He then sought payment of an additional $895. State Auto claims
there was an accord and satisfaction with respect to the amount due for services
rendered by Dr. Allen. What are the requirements of an accord and satisfaction? Were
those requirements met in this case?