industries include oil and gas, auto industry, and fossil-fuel based utilities (coal, oil, and
gas). Those industries did undertake voluntary reductions following the demise of the
Kyoto Protocol. To date, businesses and industries in the United States have achieved
one-half of the reductions that Kyoto would have mandated.
The 1,000+ e-mails from the scientists at CRI reveal what MIT scientist Michael
Schrage has called “malice, mischief, and Machiavellian maneuverings” among the
scientists with regard to their data and research on climate change. The e-mails include
the following revelations:
•Ongoing efforts to manipulate the peer-review process for manuscripts that were
submitted for publication in academic journals if those manuscripts challenged the
research and conclusions of CRI scientists.
From: Phil Jones. To: Many. March 11, 2003
“I will be emailing the journal to tell them I”m having nothing more to do with it until they
rid themselves of this troublesome editor.”
Professor Jones appears to be lobbying for the dismissal of the editor of Climate Research,
a scientific journal that published papers downplaying climate change.
From Phil Jones To: Michael Mann (Pennsylvania State University). July 8, 2004
“I can’t see either of these papers being in the next IPCC report. Kevin and I will keep
them out somehow ” even if we have to redefine what the peer-review literature is!”
•There was considerable disagreement acrimony among the CRI scientists about the
results, meaning, and interpretation of their data and work ” something not revealed
in either their publications or speeches.
•Significant portions of data from CRI were withheld from public disclosure or
examination by scientists outside CRI.
•University of Arizona professor Jonathan Overpeck expressed concern to his
colleagues in the e-mails, “Please write all e-mails as though they will be made
public.”
•CRI scientists ignored requests for the release of raw data.
•One CRI scientist deleted his e-mails after demands for the data were made public.
However, he neglected to delete an e-mail that revealed his actions in response to a
British Freedom of Information Act (BFOIA), “I am supposed to go through my