CHAPTER 20: FORMATION OF SALES AND LEASE CONTRACTS 11
ESSAY QUESTIONS
B1. On May 1, Newtown Motors, a used-car dealer, wrote a letter to O’Reilly, which
stated, “We have a 1969 Pontiac Firebird in mint condition that we will sell you
for $12,500 at any time before June 1. [Signed] Newtown Motors.” By May 15,
having heard nothing from O’Reilly, Newtown Motors sold the Firebird to
another party. On May 25, O’Reilly told Newtown Motors that he accepted the
offer and tendered $12,500. When Newtown Motors told O’Reilly it had sold the
car to another party, O’Reilly claimed Newtown Motors had breached their
contract. Is Newtown Motors in breach? Explain.
B2. NationPoints Trucking, Inc., has a requirements contract with Oil & Gas
Corporation that obligates Oil & Gas to supply NationPoints with all the
gasoline it needs for its vehicles for one year at $2.30 per gallon. A clause
inserted in small print in the contract by NationPoints, and not noticed by Oil &
Gas, states, “The buyer reserves the right to reject any shipment for any
reason without liability.”
For six months, NationPoints orders and Oil & Gas delivers under the
contract without any controversy. Then, because of a war in the Middle East,
the price of gasoline to Oil & Gas increases substantially. Oil & Gas tells
NationPoints it cannot possibly fulfill their contract unless NationPoints agrees
to pay $2.50 per gallon. NationPoints, in need of the gasoline, agrees in writing
to modify the contract.
Later that month, NationPoints learns it can buy gasoline at $2.40 per
gallon from Purified Fuel Company. NationPoints refuses delivery of its most
recent order from Oil & Gas, claiming, first that the contract allows it to do so
without liability, and second, that it is required to pay only $2.30 per gallon if it
accepts the delivery. Discuss NationPoints’s contentions.