Collins, Business Ethics 3e
SAGE Publishing, 2021
47. An HR manager is conducting an ethical decision-making workshop for new
employees. After reviewing the critical thinking decision-making process, a fictional
ethical dilemma is introduced, possible solutions offered, and the group is asked which
answer is correct. One attendee offers a fourth possible answer. What should the HR
manager do?
a. Explain that proposed solutions which are not a part of the training are not helpful.
b. Ask other attendees what they think of the proposed solution and discuss.
c. Explain, briefly, why the suggested solution is not an option in order to save time and
keep the conversation focused.
d. Suggest that the solution might be viable and that employees must use their best
judgment in such situations.
48. In an ethical decision-making workshop, what activity should a facilitator introduce
after introducing the hypothetical ethical dilemma?
a. Have participants vote by secret ballot on the best solution, then tally the votes and
share the results with the workshop.
b. Have participants break out into small groups and discuss possible solutions.
c. Have participants write down a single sentence describing what they think to be the
best possible course of action.
d. Have participants write answers to the seven systematic rational ethical decision–
making process questions.
49. What is the value in quickly tallying the votes on possible solutions in an ethical
decision-making workshop?
a. It helps attendees understand the complexity of the issues by showing that not
everyone will agree on solutions.
b. It helps force those who make the wrong ethical decisions to take accountability for
bad choices.
c. It shows attendees that there can be many right answers to an ethical dilemma.
d. It allows for quick, multiple revotes to demonstrate how consensus can be achieved
with subsequent ethical training.