Hanna intends to give her granddaughter, Melodee, her antique hat pin. This heirloom
has been kept under lock and key in the wall vault in the library of Hannas house in
Virginia. The hat pin is currently the only item in the vault. When Hanna is visiting
Melodee in Connecticut, Hanna gives Melodee the only key to the vault. Melodee is
grateful for the present and excitedly accepts. In this situation has there been a
completed gift?
a. No. There has been no physical delivery of the hat pin.
b. Yes. There has been physical delivery of the hat pin.
c. No. There has only been constructive delivery of the hat pin.
d. Yes. There has been constructive delivery of the hat pin.
A college professor copies seven chapters from a book called “How to Get Better
GradesA Creative Approach to College Success!” There are ten chapters in the book.
She incorporates this material into a packet of material that is printed in her college’s
copy center. The packet is then placed in the local book store and is placed on the
required materials list for students to purchase. The author of the book on getting better
grades believes the professor has violated his copyright.
a. The author is right. The professor should not have copied the chapters and placed
them for sale in the bookstore.
b. The author is technically correct. However, even though an infringement occurred, he
cannot sue the professor since educational personnel are exempt from liability under
copyright law.
c. The author is not correct. Under the “fair use doctrine” a college professor can copy