Imogene takes her diamond solitaire ring to Sparkle Jewelry Shop to have the prongs
holding the diamond retipped and have the ring cleaned. The clerk at Sparkle says she
will have to leave the ring and that it should be ready in about a week. When Imogene
returns in a week to get her ring, she finds out that the ring has been sold. Which of the
following is true?
a. Sparkle Jewelry Shop had the power to transfer all of Imogene’s rights in the ring to a
good faith buyer in the ordinary course of business.
b. This situation was a theft of the ring by Sparkle, and Sparkle must retrieve the ring
and return it to Imogene.
c. The buyer of the ring must return it to Imogene since the buyer did not fully
investigate whether Sparkle had good title to the ring.
d. Imogene has lost title to her ring and has no recourse since she is responsible for
investigating the merchant’s integrity before leaving her property.
When the per se standard applies, the plaintiff:
a. needs only to prove the existence of the conduct.
b. must prove that the activity was an unreasonable restraint of trade.
c. must show that there was an anti-competitive impact.
d. None of the above.