c.plaintiff
d.employer
Bailey’s Brake Service, a bit of an eyesore at a main intersection near the faltering
downtown area of Mesa, Arizona, was a family-founded, owned and operated business
that had been open in its existing location since 1970. Lenhardt’s True Value Hardware
store was also a longstanding Mesa business with a location south and east of Bailey’s
and a desire for a better location as well as a professed desire to revitalize Mesa’s
downtown area. The Lenhardts had purchased the property abutting Bailey’s but felt
that the streetfacing Bailey’s property was necessary for its location, location, location.
The city fathers and mothers were in favor of condemnation of the Bailey use, a taking
by eminent domain, followed by a “reissuing” of the once Bailey property to Lenhardt’s
for its construction of a new and much less eyesoreish retail establishment on the site:
Randy Bailey challenged the taking of his business as unconstitutional. Discuss the
issues in his case and challenge
to the city’s taking by eminent domain.