In DiMercurio v. Sphere Drake Insurance, DiMercurio was a fisherman who worked on
a boat in Massachusetts. The boat was insured by a British insurance company, Sphere
Drake. The boat DiMercurio worked on sank and he was injured. The company he
worked for could not pay the damages DiMercurio won against them in court but gave
their rights against its insurer, Sphere Drake, to DiMercurio. The insurance policy
between the boat owners and Sphere Drake included an arbitration clause. Sphere
Drake sought to enforce the arbitration while DiMercurio argued that it would be too
burdensome on the parties that he would have to travel to London for arbitration. The
appellate court held that:
A.the international travel was overly burdensome and the arbitration clause was not
valid.
B.DiMercurio did not agree to the arbitration clause with Sphere Drake, the boat owner
did, therefore the arbitration clause is not valid.
C.the arbitration clause is valid because arbitration clauses once agreed on are always
valid.
D.the arbitration clause is valid under a four-part analysis that included the
consideration of the commercial relationship having a reasonable relation with a foreign
country.
Mike raped Kathy in the parking lot of Tom’s Pub. The Attorney General/District
Attorney’s office prosecuted Mike on rape charges. Subsequently, Kathy filed a lawsuit
against Mike for money damages. Classify each legal action.
A.the Attorney General/District Attorney’s case was a criminal case, Jane’s lawsuit was
a civil case
B.the Attorney General/District Attorney’s case was a civil case, Jane’s lawsuit was a
criminal case
C.both cases are criminal