Voir dire is a process for presenting evidence in a case.
Only outsiders who would ordinarily be deemed fiduciaries of the corporations in
whose stock they trade can be liable for insider trading.
In May 2012, National Biotech Corporation generally advertises that it will make a $4
million offering of stock in June. National makes the offering as advertised and, ten
days after the first sale, notifies the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). All
buyers of the stock are given material information about the company, its business, and
the stock. Before the end of the year, the offering is completely sold out. The buyers
include forty unaccredited investors and fifty accredited investors. National does not
register the offering. The SEC files a suit against National, seeking civil sanctions on
the ground that this offering was not exempt from registration. National argues that the
applicable exemption is Rule 505 of Regulation D of the Securities Act of 1933 and that
because of this exemption, any resale of the stock is also exempt. Who is correct?