When an accord and satisfaction is agreed to, the original obligation subject to the
accord is immediately discharged.
In Butters v. Vance International Inc, Vance International was hired to provide security
for the Saudi royal family while they were in California. Butters was employed by
Vance International as a security officer. She was assigned to the Saudi detail and
worked occasionally as an acting supervisor in a security command post. Vance
International recommended to the Saudis that Butters be promoted to a full rotation in
the command post. The Saudis rejected this recommendation on their belief that it was
against Islamic law to have a woman in the command post. Butters sued for gender
discrimination for the loss of promotion. Vance International argued that they were
immune under the Federal Sovereign Immunities Act because they were carrying out
the orders of a foreign government. The court found that:
A.Vance International was not immune because the discrimination took place on
American soil.
B.Vance International was not immune because the Saudis waived immunity by hiring
an American security company.
C.Vance International was immune because the Saudis were performing an act peculiar
to a sovereign and not a commercial activity.
D.Vance International was immune because U.S. courts recognize the jurisdiction of
Saudi’s laws for Saudi nationals in the U.S.