24.3 Scenario Questions
The following question(s) are based on the observation that several dozen different proteins
comprise the prokaryotic flagellum and its attachment to the prokaryotic cell, producing a highly
complex structure.
1) If the complex protein assemblage of the prokaryotic flagellum arose by the same general
processes as those of the complex eyes of molluscs (such as squids and octopi), then
A) natural selection cannot account for the rise of the prokaryotic flagellum.
B) ancestral versions of this protein assemblage were either less functional or had different
functions than modern prokaryotic flagella.
C) scientists should accept the conclusion that neither eyes nor flagella could have arisen by
evolution.
2) Certain proteins of the complex motor that drives bacterial flagella are modified versions of
proteins that had previously belonged to plasma membrane pumps. This evidence supports the
claim that
A) some structures are so complex that natural selection cannot, and will not, explain their
origins.
B) the power of natural selection allows it to act in an almost predictive fashion, producing
organs that will be needed in future environments.
C) the motors of bacterial flagella were originally synthesized abiotically.
D) structures originally adapted for one purpose can take on new functions through descent with
modification.
E) bacteria that possess flagella must have lost the ability to pump certain chemicals across their
plasma membranes.