1.3 Scenario Questions
Please use the following information to answer the following question(s).
The collared lizard is a species found in the Desert Southwest. Male collared lizards show
considerable color variation, ranging from brightly colored to a very dull pattern. Your goal is to
determine the function, if any, of male color patterns in collared lizards, using the scientific
method. Your tentative explanation is that male color plays a role in attracting females for
mating purposes. You predict that females will preferentially choose brightly colored males over
dull-colored ones. To test your prediction, you observed the interactions of female collared
lizards with their male counterparts. You selected males that were the same age and size, and that
differed only in their coloration pattern. You placed equal numbers of the two types of male
lizards, bright and dull, in aquariums, along with one female lizard per aquarium. Out of 350
aquariums observed, the female chose to mate with the brightly colored male 277 times, and the
dull-colored male 70 times. In three instances, the females did not mate with either type.
Create a bar graph of your data, plotting the type of male (dull or brightly colored) on the x-axis.
On the y-axis, plot the frequency with which each type of male was chosen by females. Using
this graph, answer the following questions.
1) Is it reasonable to conclude (i.e., is it supported by the data) that female collared lizards prefer
more brightly colored male lizards over dull-colored males?
A) Yes, this conclusion is supported by the data.
B) No, this conclusion is not supported by the data.
C) The data do not clearly indicate a preference one way or the other.
D) None of the above choices are correct.
2) Dull-colored males were used in this experiment to ________.
A) serve as a comparison (control) group to the brightly colored males
B) be sure that females could recognize the gender of the other lizards
C) give the experiment more trials so that the data would be more persuasive
D) be sure all females had a male with which they could mate