CRPR.SAMA.18.02.08 – Understand and appreciate that the difficulty to define due process
is historically rooted in the controversial issues of states’ rights and equal rights for all
citizens. Gradually, the U.S. Supreme Court expanded the meaning of criminal procedure
rights within the federal system and ruled that most of these rights apply to state and local
criminal justice, too.
63. Summarize the differences among the fundamental fairness, total incorporation, and selective incorporation doctrines
as they influence state criminal procedures.
Below is an example of a correct answer to this question. There are other ways to answer the
question that may also be correct.
The fundamental fairness doctrine focused on general fairness. Under this doctrine states
could largely define their own criminal procedures, as long as they did not offend
fundamental rights.
Under the total incorporation doctrine, all provisions of the Bill of Rights were considered
incorporated into the Fourteenth Amendment due process clause and thus applicable to the
states. Under this doctrine, states in a criminal justice system would have to follow
identically all those rights guaranteed to the accused in federal criminal proceedings.
Finally, the selective incorporation doctrine argued that some provisions of the Bill of Rights
were incorporated into the notion of due process and thus applicable against the states, and
some were not. When a right was considered so fundamental as to be incorporated into the
due process clause and applied to the states, the states would have to apply that right exactly
as it was in a federal criminal proceeding.
CRPR.SAMA.18.02.09 – Know, understand, and appreciate that after a decades-long
struggle, a Supreme Court majority came to agree that “due process” requires the
incorporation of the specific criminal procedure provisions in the U.S. Bill of Rights and that
incorporation changed day-to–day criminal procedure by expanding its intervention from the
courtroom to public spaces and not-so-public police stations.