In Strickland v. Washington, SCOTUS adopted a two-prong test to decide whether counsel
has provided effective assistance in a criminal case. Under the first prong, called the
reasonableness prong, the defendant has to prove that the lawyer’s performance wasn’t
reasonably competent—the lawyer was so deficient that he or she “was not functioning as the
‘counsel’ guaranteed the defendant by the Sixth Amendment.” This is judged by looking at
the totality of facts and circumstances surrounding the trial and the lawyer’s performance.
If the defendant first proves that a lawyer’s performance was unreasonable, the defendant
must still meet a second prong, called the prejudice prong. Under this part of the test, the
defendant has to prove that the lawyer’s incompetence was probably responsible for the
defendant’s conviction.
CRPR.SAMA.18.12.04 – Know the types of defense counsel; understand the scope and limits
of the right to counsel; and appreciate the differences between the rights of those who can
afford lawyers and those who can’t.
65. List and describe the differences between testing the government’s case by preliminary hearing and testing it by grand
jury review.
The goal of both a preliminary hearing and a grand jury review is to decide whether there is
enough evidence to bring a defendant to trial. The preliminary hearing process stresses
adversarial, open, accusatory values and control by experts. The grand jury review
underscores the value of lay participation in criminal proceedings.
Preliminary hearings are public; grand jury proceedings are secret. Preliminary hearings are
adversarial proceedings in which the defense can challenge the prosecution’s case; grand
juries hear only the prosecution’s case. Judges preside over preliminary hearings; prosecutors
manage grand juries. In preliminary hearings, judges determine whether there is enough
evidence to proceed to trial; grand jury reviews rely on grand jurors (citizens selected to
serve a term) to decide whether there is enough evidence to go to trial. Finally, defendants
and their lawyers attend preliminary hearings; in grand jury reviews, defendants and their
lawyers are not present.
Testing the Government’s Case
CRPR.SAMA.18.12.05 – Understand preliminary hearings and grand jury reviews and how
they differ from trials.
DATE CREATED:
1/6/2017 12:00 AM
DATE MODIFIED:
1/6/2017 2:30 AM