Indicate one or more answer choices that best complete the statement or answer the question.
18. Which of the following considerations determines whether a measure is ordinary or extraordinary?
a. whether the measure is likely to benefit the patient
b. whether the measure represents common medical practice
c. whether the treatment is voluntary
d. whether the treatment is legal
19. Critics of the distinction between ordinary versus extraordinary measures have complained that the idea of what
counts as extraordinary is
a. immoral
b. heroic
c. vain
d. vague
Label as types of euthanasia: Voluntary Active (VA), Voluntary Passive withholding Ordinary Measures (VPO),
Voluntary Passive withholding Extraordinary Measures (VPEx), or (using the same names with NV for non-voluntary)
Non-voluntary Active (NVA), Non-voluntary Passive withholding Ordinary Measures (NVPO), Non-voluntary Passive
withholding Extraordinary Measures (NVPEx).
20. A dying patient asks that no more chemotherapy be given because it is doing nothing but prolonging her death, which
is inevitable in a short time anyway.
21. Parents of a newborn who is dying no matter what is done ask that doctors not do anything else to prolong its life.
22. A person who has terminal cancer takes an overdose of sleeping pills so that he will be able to die when and how he
wishes.
23. A person who has serious lung problems and has been temporarily placed on a respirator asks that she be removed
from a respirator that is causing her great discomfort.
24. Give a deontological argument for legalizing active euthanasia and a deontological argument against it.
25. James Rachels employs a thought experiment involving two men, Smith and Jones, who Rachels suggests demonstrate
that killing someone is not necessarily morally worse than letting someone die. Describe Rachels’ thought experiment and
explain how it is supposed to relate to the morality of passive and active euthanasia. What conclusions does Rachels draw
about the moral significance of the distinction between active and passive euthanasia?
26. Give a consequentialist argument for legalizing active euthanasia and a consequentialist argument against it.