Possible Conditions
Occurrence A B C D E F Phenomenon
1 * – – * * – –
2 * * * * – * *
3 – * * – * * *
4 * – – – – * –
5 * * – * * – *
6 – * * – * * –
12. What cause is suggested by the information in Table 5A?
a. C is a sufficient but not a necessary condition for the phenomenon.
b. B is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for the phenomenon.
c. F is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for the phenomenon.
d. D is a sufficient but not a necessary condition for the phenomenon.
e. C is a necessary condition for the phenomenon.
13. Suppose that the owner of an older model Porsche Carrera notices that it takes 7 percent longer for her car to
accelerate from zero to sixty than it did when the car was new. From a book relating to relevant parameters, she calculates
that 2 percent of the reduction can be attributed to the fact that the car now has larger tires. Also, the alcohol content of the
gas accounts for 2 percent, dirty spark plugs for 1 percent, and the fact that she now lives in Los Angeles, where the air is
thicker than it was in Denver, where she bought the car, accounts for 1 percent. The owner attributes the remaining 1
percent to general aging of the engine. What method did the owner use in drawing this conclusion?
a. The joint method of agreement and difference.
b. The method of agreement.
c. The method of difference.
d. The method of concomitant variation.
e. The method of residues.
14. Suppose that a philosophy professor is able to monitor the amount of time her logic students spend working on a
computerized tutorial program. When the students spend 5 hours on the program, their average grade increases by 4
percentage points. When they spend 10 hours on the program, their average grade increases by an additional 4 percentage
points, and when they spend 15 hours working on the program, their grades increase by yet an additional 4 percentage
points. The professor concludes that work on the tutorial program causes an increase in student grades. What method did
the professor use in drawing this conclusion?
a. The method of difference.
b. The method of agreement.
c. The method of concomitant variation.
d. The method of residues.
e. The joint method of agreement and difference.
15. The method used by Henrietta Swan Leavitt in her discovery involving Cepheids, which is described in your textbook,
is similar to:
a. The method of agreement.
b. The method of residues.
c. The method of difference.