A) Analyze the argument passage below, addressing the following as appropriate: specify
the issues addressed; identify premises and conclusions; classify as inductive or
deductive; supply missing premises; separate arguments from window dressing; identify
claims better left unstated. B) Diagram the argument.
Let’s see. I know our policy covers us if our car is stolen or if the windows are broken, so
chances are it’ll cover us if someone steals the stereo, too. Besides that, our homeowners
policy covers stereos, and our car policy seems to cover a lot of the same stuff the
homeowners policy covers.
Answers will vary.
Analyze the argument passage below, addressing the following as appropriate: specify the
issues addressed; identify premises and conclusions; classify as inductive or deductive;
supply missing premises; separate arguments from window dressing; identify claims better
left unstated. You may want to diagram the argument. Is there an unstated conclusion?
The competition employs a sliding mechanism. But a hinged door is lighter and easier to
operate and ensures a better fit and seal with the body than a sliding mechanism, thus
keeping the cabin’s interior noise level to a minimum. And it allows for greater freedom in
the shape of the vehicle.
—Adapted from Mazda truck product manager Bernie Chaisson, arguing that the new
Mazda MPV’s door setup is superior to that of Chrysler minivans