42. Compare original jurisdiction with appellate jurisdiction as to scope and setting.
Original jurisdiction involves the initial hearing of the case. The court with original jurisdiction makes decisions
as to the charges to be filed, evidence to be received, procedure to be followed, etc., so as to determine the facts
43. Josie was recently arrested on charges of breaking and entering, driving without a license, and possession of
a controlled substance. Although this is Josie’s third arrest prior to her fifteenth birthday, her parents want her
trial conducted in juvenile court. Because of Josie’s repeated offenses, the prosecuting attorney wants Josie tried
as an adult. What are the advantages to Josie of being tried in juvenile court?
Answers will vary. Society typically feels that juveniles should not be held as responsible as adults for their
criminal acts. Because of this belief, juvenile courts have wide discretionary powers in determining what should
44. Marlon lives in Seattle, Washington, and travels extensively on business trips throughout the country. While
in South Carolina he reads an advertisement for a classic 1959 BMW selling for $80,000. Because Marlon
collects rare and unique automobiles, he decides to locate the seller and examine the vehicle. After examining
the condition of the vehicle and its various options, he agrees to the selling price and gives the seller (Ted) a
check for $80,000. Ted agrees to have the car delivered to Marlon’s home in Seattle within the next two weeks.
After three weeks, Marlon has not received his car, but his $80,000 check has been cashed. He contacts Ted, but
Ted says he will now need an additional $5,000 to pay for a driver to drive the car from South Carolina to
Seattle, Washington. Marlon decides to sue Ted to recover either the vehicle or the $80,000. In which court will
Marlon’s attorney file the lawsuit? Explain why this court will have jurisdiction over the matter.
Marlon’s attorney will need to file the case in a federal district court rather than a state court. Because Marlon