BTCF = – Capital Investment + GI – Expense
MACRS: from Table 7.3 and dk=rkB
BV8= 0; therefore, Depreciation recapture =4000
TI = GI – Expense – Depreciation + Depreciation recapture
Taxes = TI (t)
ATCF = BTCF – Taxes
Machine Q:
Year BTCF rkDepreciation TI Taxes ATCF
0–380,000 – – – – – 380,000
1150,000 0.1429 54,302.00 95,698.00 33,494.30 116,505.70
2150,500 0.2449 93,062.00 57,438.00 20,103.30 130,396.70
… … … … … … …
8157,500 0.0446 16,948.00 140,552.00 49,193.20 108,306.80
AWQ(12%) = – $380,000(A/P, 12%, 8) + [$116,505.70 (P/F, 12%, 1) +$130,396.70
(P/F, 12%, 2) +
…+$111,326.90 (P/F, 12%, 7)] (A/P, 12%, 8) +$108,306.80 (A/F,
12%, 8)
= – $380,000( (0.2013) +$116,505.70 (0.8929) +$130,396.70 (0.7972) +
…
+$111,326.90 (0.4523)](0.2013) +$108,306.80 (0.0813)
=$40,392.67
Machine R:
Year BTCF rkDepreciation TI Taxes ATCF
0–395,000 – – – – – 395,000
1152,500 0.1429 56,445.50 96,054.50 33,619.08 118,880.92
2152,500 0.2449 96,735.50 55,764.50 19,517.58 132,982.42
… … … … … … …
8152,500 0.0446 17,617.00 134,883.00 47,209.05 105,290.95
9–10 152,500 –152,500 5,337,500.00 99,125.00
AWR(12%) = – $395,000 (A/P, 12%, 10) + $[118,880.92 (P/F, 12%, 1) +132,982.42
(P/F, 12%, 2) +
…+99,125.00 (P/F, 12%, 9)] (A/P, 12%, 10) +$99,125.00 (A/F, 12%,
10)
= – $395,000 (0.1770) + $[118,880.92 (0.8929) +132,982.42 (0.7972) +…
+99,125.00 (0.3606)] (0.1770) +$99,125.00 (0.0570)
=$45,882.31
AWR>AWQ> 0; therefore, alternative R should be selected.