Ryan Lippert
POL 150
MWF 10:10-11
Poverty Project
I. A structure is defined as “an organization of parts as dominated by the general character
of the whole” (Structure, Merriam-Webster, 2017). With this definition in mind, the topic of
poverty can be viewed as more than a mere condition; instead, it is a single structure composed
of various constraints. Such constraints as place, resources and political economy unfortunately
misaligned can serve as pillars for oppression and walls in which those born within struggle to
escape. The challenges increase when an individual within these constraints also belongs to
several minority groups. An example would be the African-American male who also practices
Islam, also known as a Black Muslim. Regrettably, the prospect of escaping such a poverty
construct can be dismal, but in the name of humanity and in order for our nation to progress, we
cannot ignore this great need to establish some prescribed practices to aid in this escape from
poverty. It is my strong-held belief that education – with particular emphasis on social stigmas
holds tremendous power in the battle against poverty and its many compounding effects. An
exploration into three cities spanning the United States, including Bridgeport, Connecticut;
Birmingham, Alabama; and Los Angeles, California, provide a picture of how the structural
constraints of poverty impact Black Muslims.
II. An individual is the sum of many parts. One may identify themselves by gender, race,
religion, sexual preference and more depending on a particular context, yet somehow these
identifiers still fail to scratch the surface of who a person really is. As described by Susan J.
Ferguson in Race, Gender, Sexuality, and Social Class: Dimensions of Inequality and Identity,
“. . . every identity is unique . . . our identities derive from our particular experiences in the
world which are unlikely to overlap with others” (p. 155). Ferguson expands on this notion of
identity by adding, “. . . they are social and depend on context. In other words, they are both
private and public property others have a say in who a person becomes” (p. 164). This point is
further emphasized when considering the identity of race. Race refers to each of the major
divisions of humankind having distinct physical characteristics such as skin tone. For example,
in public, it is not uncommon for the African American identity to be subjected to a barrage of
stereotypes. From absentee fathers to criminal intent, assumptions made about another based on
their race is a longstanding issue struggled with daily in our country. Deplorably, it is this
presumptive behavior that helps perpetuate the cycle of poverty. If a community member or
policy maker can blame an individual or group’s unfortunate predicament on assumptions about
their race (e.g. lazy) there becomes far less motivation to enact change. What is more, and
perhaps most disheartening, is the individual suffering these egregious stigmas may resort to
behaving in the way society expects – known colloquially as the self-fulling prophecy.
For individuals such as the Black Muslims considered in this essay, the struggles of
living below the poverty line are compounded by their unique identities as members of multiple
minority groups as well as societal views they must endure. Ferguson explains, “. . . if social
category matters in a given community and if a person claims an association with this category,
or if others associate her with this category, that category will have some impact on her
behavior” (p. 157). Such a social category would include one most significant to the Black
Muslim: Religion. As defined by the Merriam Webster dictionary, religion is “a set of beliefs
concerning the cause, nature and purpose of the universe . . . usually involving devotional and
ritual observances, and often containing a moral code for the conduct of human affairs
(Religion, Merriam-Webster, 2017). Describing their experience, “nearly all American-born
black Muslims (96%) say there is a lot of discrimination against Muslims in America, almost
identical to those who say there is a lot of discrimination against black people in the United
States (94%). Additionally, U.S. Muslims say it has become harder in recent years to be Muslim
in the United States” (Greenwood, 2017).
Poverty is not a new phenomenon. Though much of the landscape has changed, the
prevalence of poverty in America has alarmingly endured. As author, Stephen Pimpare,
describes in his 2011 book, A People’s History of Poverty in America, “Among ‘advanced’
nations, we have the highest, or almost the highest, rates of poverty (highest), childhood poverty
(highest), elderly poverty (second highest), long-term poverty (highest), permanent poverty
(highest) and income inequality (highest)” (p. 232). As part of his 2014 data portrait, Drew
DeSilver, offers additional insight into poverty and the African American community when he
wrote in Who’s poor in America? 50 years into the War on Poverty, In 1966 . . . four-inten
(41%) of African-Americans were poor; blacks constituted nearly a third (31.1%) of all poor
Americans. By 2012, poverty among African-Americans had fallen to 27.2% – still more than
double the rate among whites (12.7%) (DeSilver, 2014). DeSilver continues his exploration of
poverty by comparing interesting shifts in the poverty paradigm, such as a majority of those in
poverty today – 57% – are of working age, 18-64 years old. In 1959, the percentage was only
41.7%. Another shift can be found in the household structure within low-income communities.
DeSilver recites, “In 1973 . . . more than half (51.4%) of poor families were headed by a married
couple; 45.4% were headed by women. In 2012, just over half (50.3%) of poor families were
female-headed, while 38.9% were headed by married couples (DeSilver, 2014). Poverty’s effect
on education is equally disheartening. In their July 2011 Education Research and Review article,
The Effects of Poverty on Academic Achievement, authors Lecour and Tissington explain a U.S.
Department of Education study of third through fifth grade students from 71 high-poverty
schools. “Students scored below norms in all years and grades tested; students who lived in
poverty scored significantly worse than other students” (p. 522). It is within these impoverished
communities that education is most important and yet is most lacking.
III. For many African Americans living below the poverty line (25.4% compared to the
national average of 14.7% according to the U. S. Census in 2015), the negative effects of poverty
extend far beyond the classroom; it is a way of life. Though the Civil Rights Movement ended
over 50 years ago, the continued prevalence of discrimination and even, segregation are still
heavily witnessed in the United States. As cited in Racial Conflict, author Peter Katel quotes
Maya Rockeymoore, CEO of Global Policy Solutions, “We still have segregation across
American geospatially, with housing practices and banking practices that actually retarded if not