Author’s
Assumption
Assumptions
made
Evidence
Provided
Type of
Evidence
Your commentary
(Support, Refute,
Qualify)
That people will
most likely
remember the
day if
something
significant
happens on
that day
That an alibi is
important that could
be important
The author goes
around and asks
people what
they did the day
Hae went
missing.
Sources
I can testify that I will
most likely
remember how the
day went if
something
significant happens
that day.
That Adnan
was doing all
this stuff was
against his
religion
That Adnan was
going out of his
religion in order to
be with the girl he
loved. (Hae)
In the first
episode, Koeing
stated when he
talked to Adnan
that he was
going behind his
parents. A good
example is the
prom dance.
Experience
I don’t know much
about the religion
but I believe he
could’ve gone out of
his religion knowing
that their religion is
pretty strict.
That Adnan is a
suspect
because he is
Hae’s ex
That the ex could
be feeling some
type of way after a
breakup
The cops made
Adnan a heavy
target since he
was the ex and
that the
evidence to
support that,
much a bit
against Adnan.
Evidence
This could be a
possibility since he
is an ex which
makes him
automatically a
suspect.
That Mr.S
storyline
doesn’t match
up with the
images and the
fact that it was
impossible to
just spot the
body.
That Mr. S
reasoning didn’t
seem to add up
and that maybe he
could be trying to
bail the killing from
being him.
In the episode
when Mr. S
testified how he
found the body
and that he went
to pee and
discovered
where the body
was buried.
Testimony
I don’t think this is
reliable since he was
a criminal and why
he would bring more
attention to himself if
he was really the
killer.
That Mr. S had
heard about the
body from his
step kids or
neighbors and
The author was
trying to see if Mr.
S was a possible
killer or maybe the
kids knew and he
There wasn’t
much evidence
to prove this,
other than the
author assuming
Testimony,
Evidence,
Sources
I find this theory to
be really
inconclusive and not
enough to point him
to be a suspect
that he was
told.
was looking for it
himself
this to be a
possibility.
She believes
that the cell
record and jay’s
story doesn’t
match up at all.
The cell record
plays an important
part in this
investigation
regarding whether
everyone’s story
matches up with
cell records
There was
evidence of 21
different calls
within the day
Hae went
missing and
they are trying
to see whether it
matches up with
everyone’s
story.
Cell
Record,
Evidence
I found this to be the
biggest key to this
investigation and
seeing where
everyone was at, at
the time of Hae
disappearance.
That cell
records aren’t
reliable sources
of information
That a butt dial or
accidental calls
don’t make cell
records totally
reliable.
That the weird
phone call and
3:21 could have
been a mistake
since Jay was
already at
Jenn’s house
Cell
Record,
Evidence
I find this odd since
why does Jay have
to call Jenn if he is
supposedly at her
house?
That Adnan
wasn’t over the
That this could be a
possibility that
The author
theoretical
Evidence,
Source
I find this to be a
possibility and that
together.
didn’t really
the week
started.
That Adnan
It was claimed by
Hae acted normal
It was stated in
with Adnan, that
rides and that
they were still
cool even
though she and
Don were
together.
Testimony
I myself find this
don’t know whether
heart
