Chapter 6 Momentum Analysis of Flow Systems
6-47 Water is pumped through a piping section. The moment acting on the elbow for the cases of
downward and upward discharge is to be determined.
Assumptions 1 The flow is steady and incompressible. 2 The water is discharged to the atmosphere, and
thus the gage pressure at the outlet is zero. 3 Effects of water falling down during upward discharge is
disregarded. 4 Pipe outlet diameter is small compared to the moment arm, and thus we use average values
of radius and velocity at the outlet.
Properties We take the density of water to be 1000 kg/m3.
Analysis We take the entire pipe as the control volume, and designate the inlet by 1 and the outlet by 2. We
also take the x and y coordinates as shown. The control volume and the reference frame are fixed.
The conservation of mass equation for this one-inlet one-outlet steady flow system is
, and Vmmm &&& == 21 VV =
21 since Ac = constant. The mass flow rate and the weight of the horizontal
section of the pipe are
kg/s24.45)m/s 4](4/m) 12.0()[ kg/m(1000 23 ===
πρ
VAm c
&
N/m 3.294
m/s kg1
N 1
)m/s 81.9)(m 2)( kg/m(15 2
2=
⋅
== mgW
(a) Downward discharge: To determine the moment acting on the pipe at point A, we need to take the
moment of all forces and momentum flows about that point. This is a steady and uniform flow problem,
and all forces and momentum flows are in the same plane. Therefore, the angular momentum equation in
this case can be expressed as
∑−=
inout
VmrVmrM && where r is the moment arm, all moments in the
counterclockwise direction are positive, and all in the clockwise direction are negative.
2
Vm
&
1
Vm
&
r2 = 1 m r1 = 2 m
A
•
W
The free body diagram of the pipe section is given in the figure. Noting that the moments of all
forces and momentum flows passing through point A are zero, the only force that will yield a moment about
point A is the weight W of the horizontal pipe section, and the only momentum flow that will yield a
moment is the outlet stream (both are negative since both moments are in the clockwise direction). Then
the angular momentum equation about point A becomes
221 VmrWrM A&
−=−
Solving for MA and substituting,
mN 70.0 ⋅−=
⋅
=−= 2
221 m/s kg1
N 1
m/s) kg/s)(4m)(45.54 (2–N) m)(294.3 1(
VmrWrM A&
The negative sign indicates that the assumed direction for MA is wrong, and should be reversed. Therefore,
a moment of 70 N⋅m acts at the stem of the pipe in the clockwise direction.
(b) Upward discharge: The moment due to discharge stream is positive in this case, and the moment
acting on the pipe at point A is
mN 659 ⋅=
⋅
+=+= 2
221 m/skg 1
N 1
m/s) kg/s)(4 m)(45.54 (2N) m)(294.3 1(VmrWrM A&
Discussion Note direction of discharge can make a big difference in the moments applied on a piping
system. This problem also shows the importance of accounting for the moments of momentums of flow
streams when performing evaluating the stresses in pipe materials at critical cross-sections.