Task 2
Chapter 1 Questions
1. A sold goods to C, at the time A sold the goods he is not yet the owner.
Is the sale valid? Why?
➢ Yes, it is still valid to sell the goods to anyone even if you
are not the owner. The fact that C has totally innocent to
purchase these items that he believed is not owned by A is
not irrelevant unless he mistakenly thought that A is the
owner this will reflect the real owner’s title
Therefore A and C are the owners of a goods.
2. Same problem. What if by accident A comingled the goods he is selling
to C, for purposes of this question, the goods are sand, with the goods of
E which is also sand. Is the sale valid? Why and how?
➢ Yes, it is still valid because does not the fault of owner A it happens
accidentally, and owner A innocent to accident, yet the goods can
still separate into two, and if owner C and E did not take the accident
seriously the sale is still valid because in the Civil Code of the
