Criticisms of Formal Planning
Formal planning may:
1. Create rigidity
2. Replace intuition and creativity
3. Focus managers’ attention on today’s
competition, not on tomorrow’s survival
4. Reinforce success, which may lead to
failure
1-6
Although it makes sense for an organization to establish goals and direction, critics
have challenged some of the basic assumptions of planning.
1. Planning may create rigidity with goals and a timetable that are set under
the assumption that the environment won’t change.
2. Formal plans cannot replace intuition and creativity. Planning should
enhance and support intuition and creativity, not replace it.
3. Planning focuses managers’ attention on today’s competition, not on
tomorrow’s survival. Formal planning tends to focus on how best to capitalize
on existing business opportunities instead of ways to reinvent the industry.
Instead of focusing on today, managers should plan with an eye to untapped
opportunities.
4. Formal planning reinforces success, which may lead to failure. It’s difficult to
shift from the comfort of what works to the uncertainty of the unknown.
However, managers may need to face that unknown and do things in new
ways to be even more successful.
6